For the Health of the River, the White Cloud Dam Must be Removed.

On August 1, 2025, WRWP made public its position on White Cloud Dam. In taking this position, the board feels it is speaking on behalf of a broad community, one that treasures the entire White River Watershed and whose interests extend beyond just it fishery.

To The Editor:

The White River Watershed Partnership is a group of local volunteers who, for the past 30 years, have dedicated themselves to promoting the health of the White River. In that time we have installed sensors to measure the water’s temperature, done numerous studies of the aquatic insect populations, worked to remove barriers to free fish passage, and promoted awareness of the issues revolving around the White River.

The current dam controversy now happening in White Cloud is the most important event to happen to the main branch of the White River in many years. As such, we feel compelled to weigh in on the matter, with an eye firmly fixed on what the data has been telling us.

For the health of the river, the dam must be removed.

It is a well-documented fact that White Cloud Lake has been heating the river water by impounding the water in a shallow, slow moving lake that allows the sunshine to heat the water’s temperature to such an extent that it is killing the downstream fish. Water going into the lake is often 10 degrees cooler than the water going out. Temperatures as high as 83 degrees have been recorded in the outflow. The warmer the water is, the less oxygen it contains. At these extreme temperatures, low oxygen water causes the fish to suffocate and die. This is not our opinion; it is an undeniable fact.

The upper section of the river, above the dam, is cool year round, and supports a healthy population of fish that don’t need restocking. It is naturally self-sustaining. The river below the dam suffers from serious fish dieback due to the high water temperatures, and has to be restocked annually.

Biological studies have shown that the river below the dam is capable of being the same world class fishery that the more famous Pere Marquette river is, and would be should the dam be removed.

Although the recent draw down resulted in a lot of turbidity in the water, due in part to an overly aggressive draw down rate, this is a relatively short term event. Once the river channel has established itself fully, and the lake bed muck washed away, the river will return to its pristine condition.

Finally, for these reasons, as well as for the safety of the downstream people and their residences, for the avoidance of crippling debt imposed by a dam rebuild and its subsequent, never ending maintenance and insurance costs, for unobstructed fish access to the upper river, and to once again allow nutrients to move freely through the river chan-nel, the White Cloud dam must be removed.

The Board of the White River Watershed Partnership

Our letter appeared in Near North Now on August 1, and in the
Fremont Times-Indicator on August 13.

Why we have taken a position?

Since our inception in 1995, we have helped fend off the incursion of water bottlers wanting to tap the pure ground waters up-stream of White Cloud. Then downstream, members of our board were engaged in the delisting of White Lake. In between, we rallied with others to restore fish passage through the entire North Branch, where dozens of aging culverts were replaced with natural-bottom structures.

Our Mission: To protect the unique characteristics and the natural resources of the White River Watershed by promoting education, conservation, restoration, and preservation activities.

Taking positions is part of accomplishing our mission.

As an all-volunteer organization, we operate on a shoestring. But when presented with the opportunity to work with others to fulfill our mission, we engage. A recent example, WRWP drew down from its reserve the needed seed money to get the White River Watershed Collaborative underway. Maybe the amount would be minnow-sized for other organizations, but it was more than our annual budget. In June of 2025, WRWP Board members joined over two dozen others via Zoom for a Collaborative meeting where White Cloud Dam was on the agenda.  Representatives from the breadth of our Watershed, included members from aligned organizations, plus local, state, and federal agencies heard from the EGLE Dam Safety Unit engineer. He issued the drawdown permit the following day.

Not just science, a big part of the Collaborative’s focus is on the economic benefits to the people who live in and visit the Watershed. Some live in or very near White Cloud Dam. To a person, each appreciates the entirety of our Watershed, from Oxford Swamp to well out into Lake Michigan. That said, we are compelled to advocate for restoration of a natural river.

It is our honor and duty as board members of the White River Watershed Partnership to speak out on behalf of the Watershed as a whole.

White Cloud Dam Timeline

Key milestones in the history, condition, and public process surrounding White Cloud Dam and Lake White Cloud.

1872     Dam built to hold harvested timber.

1875     Grand Rapids, Newaygo and Lake Shore Railroad builds first trestle bridge just west of the dam.

1900     Consumers Power (now Consumers Energy) converts the dam to generate electricity.

1910     Dam failure; reconstructed.

1951     Consumers Power discontinues hydroelectric operation and sells the dam to the City of White Cloud.

1986     September. Storm washes out the dam and M‑37 Bridge; DNR will not issue a permit to rebuild, but the Michigan Legislature provides an exemption for dam owners in White Cloud and Luther, Michigan.

1990     Dam reconstruction with a Federal Emergency Management Agency grant of approximately $500,000.

Trout Unlimited lawsuit does not halt construction but results in an appellate court decision that establishes a pathway to standing subsequently cited in suits and decisions concerning environmental issues within Michigan.

2014     High water overtops the dam.

2017     High water overtopped the dam.

2018     High water overtopped the dam.

2019     High water overtopped the dam.

2022     EGLE Dam Safety Unit visually inspects the dam, confirming the structural assessment as Poor.

2023     White Cloud is included in EGLE Dam Safety Unit’s Dam Risk Reduction Grant Program, receiving $222,712 (85% of project costs) for repairs identified during the 2022 visual inspection. The grant also covers a Disposition Feasibility Study.

2024     May. White Cloud receives an additional $68,425 (85% of project costs) to cover bids in excess of the engineer’s estimates; enables award of the Disposition Feasibility Study.

2024     December. White Cloud requests and receives from EGLE an additional $39,100 (85% of project cost) for steel plates to repair State Street over the Primary Spillway. WRWP sends a letter to EGLE opposing additional funding.

2025      February. GEI Consultants completes the Disposition Feasibility Study.

2025     April. Based on the Study, EGLE Dam Safety Unit asks the lead engineer from GEI Consultants for a recommendation. EGLE orders White Cloud to draw down White Cloud Lake to protect the public while the City decides whether to rebuild or remove the dam.

2025 – Public Process

White Cloud City Council has used Special Meetings to ask questions about the future of Lake White Cloud and the disposition of their dam. Consultants and engineers from the Dam Safety Unit have been present at these meetings. The public has been given the opportunity to make comments and ask questions.

Special Meeting — Original agenda to review the Disposition Feasibility Study changed to only consider GEI Consultants’ proposal to prepare the permit required for drawdown. Dan DeVaun (GEI) and Lucas Tremble & Thomas Horak (EGLE Dam Safety Unit) take questions. Council rejects GEI’s proposal and instructs the City Manager to find a different engineering firm.

EGLE issues permit; drawdown of Lake White Cloud begins the same day.

Special legal counsel outlines the City’s options and explains that if the City replaces the dam, it should expect to fund it.

Council Meeting — Three engineering firms present credentials to Council for developing the plan due to the State by early November.

Aug 12     

Next Special Meeting scheduled for September 2, with Wade Trim presenting their evaluation of structural and hydrology/hydraulic analysis done in the Disposition Feasibility Study, plus exploration of options.

WRWP Board members have been in the audience of these meetings, but did not take a position until the letter to the editor published first in Near North Now on August 1, 2025.

Through this process, City Manager April Storms has been transparent, posting on the City’s website very important documentation of the process.

Details with explanations of the exchanges between the City, its engineering firms and attorney, along with State documents and other background resources are available on the White Cloud Dam page of our website.

Other information

The Forgotten River series, where Charles Chandler and Mark Heying explore the value of the White River to their community.

Newaygo County Public Opinion – Near North Now 10/15/2018

The White River: Newaygo County’s Forgotten River Part II – Near North Now 1/20/2019

Newaygo County Public Opinion – Near North Now 4/25/2019

Newaygo County Public Opinion – Near North Now 6/23/2019

WRWP chair Ray Schinler poses questions to Mark Heying about fishing from kayak the stretch of the South Branch White River from Rotary Park to Rattlesnake Creek. White River Fishing Conditions: Round Table Discussion 4/27/2023

 

20250607_121446_900
previous arrowprevious arrow
next arrownext arrow
Shadow
 
Photos by board members William Bowen and John Stivers